CMV: Environmental antinatalists draw a self-contradictory conclusion
I want to push back on environmental forms of antinatalism, specifically the idea that because humans are harmful to the Earth, humans should stop reproducing and eventually disappear. I think that given the premises they use to make this conclusion, a better conclusion is to keep existing.
If humans have caused large-scale harm to the planet, it isn’t obvious that extinction is the most moral response. An alternative is moral responsibility: reforming our behavior and actively repairing the damage we’ve caused. In most ethical contexts, we think it’s better for a harmful agent to change and make restitution than to simply remove themselves and leave the harm unaddressed.
To use an analogy: if you damage a friend’s house, leaving halfway through the destruction is better than finishing the job, but staying to clean up and repair the damage is better still. Humans are currently the only beings capable of intentionally restoring ecosystems at scale, so eliminating future generations also eliminates the possibility of long-term repair and stewardship.
This doesn’t address all forms of antinatalism (especially those focused on suffering or consent), but if the core concern is that huma
Joaquin Delgado
@yellowdog427928
Joaquin aus Ferrol, liebt frische Ideen für Communities, Tech-News am Morgen, immer bereit für neue Kontakte.
Only @yellowdog427928 can see everyone listening in. Visitors see a rotating sample.
i go cold on people when i like them too much
a pattern i've noticed in myself. i want to change.
with friends, if i feel like things are going too well, we had too good of a hangout, they told me they love me and i'm their favourite friend (which is always true in the reverse too, i always feel like i am the one who feels stronger in friendships) etc. i start being quite cold over text.
i am the youngest person by about 30 years at my workplace on average (23). i have one colleague who's 37, but he acts young. we work together a lot/drive around a lot as part of our work. he's chatty and friendly and really talks to me. i don't have a crush on him, i don't find him attractive, but i am sure i like the attention. in person, i am eager to talk to him, to laugh and joke etc. i am excited and happy when i see him in the office and always listen when others mention him.
however, when he calls me (he needs to sometimes to ask for work things), i am so cold over the phone. he tried to make small talk and i wish he would just skip it and ask for what he's calling for (this happened yesterday, him asking about my new years and christmas). he asked for a favour and i said sure and was desperate to hang up, but he kept dragging it. over
Listening
Following